Originally Posted by gHEXjt
I think it would always be in your head. Especially if they left you, and then came back after the other person dumped them. It basically is telling you that you are their second choice, and I wouldn't take them back if that were the case. It's just like knowing, "She wanted someone else, but they didn't want her so she settled for me." And that's crap. Now, if they left the other person to come back, I don't know if I would take them back or not. It would really depend on how everything unfolded in the first place.