How do I decide?

Hello all,
Well i have a dilema, that i think about an awefull lot.
There are two girls both of whom i really like, and i really don't know which one to tell that i like her. With one of them i flirt really badly, and she flirts back, but then she occationally drops hints such as " i love you, but not like that". And the other is really shy, just like me so we don't really discuss it much. But both have told me they like other guys. Should i bother with either of them? Or how do i decide between them because i find them both so perfect? Oh and they both absolutley hate each other :sad2: