Yeah, we women can be a bit complicated at times. I relax by hanging out and studying men ;). I never really analyze the behaviors of other women. I find our thoughts to be fluctuating and too emotional.
Back to the topic:
The most important thing in a relationship or for your potential relationship is how that person makes you feel and how they feel about you--attraction. If you don't feel attraction from the personality or character that the other person presents, there is absolutely no good reason to pursue a relationship or continue a relationship with that person. Well, you can always try (like for the sake of the children, for example) but that may be a miserable relationship indeed.
The men and women discussing the information that the OP presents are basically saying what they feel are behavior they find attractive in a sexual relationship.
There are men that are attracted to girly girls or women who like weekly body pampering. There are women that like the physically playful man. There is nothing wrong with any of these things. It’s only a problem when you find yourself in such an incompatible relationship.
Sheepingly, the guy may be doing those things because he likes you. Do you find him attractive in the physical and personality way?