Yes, I know better than someone who's thinking 100% on emotion after going through a terrible experience. She's not thinking logically, and neither are you.
You're obviously not used to people disagreeing with you, and you have to jump to emotional attacks when it happens. Hopefully you can get past that. As for now, yes, people that have been giving this advice in here for years are going to disagree with you and her. We've seen hundreds of people come in here that are just like her. Coddling isn't the way to go, especially with the path she's going down. Recognizing the need to get over it, and immediately taking action in that direction is the best path.
You have every right to speak and defend her. More power to you, especially since you think you're doing the right thing. But, you do have to accept that a lot of us are going to fight it, because we want what's best for her too.