
Originally Posted by
TheEvilJester
So, until the very end of your post, here is what I was thinking....
If it matters that much to him, then why not just go to his concerts now and then? It's one thing if he expected you to go all the time when it isn't really something you enjoy, but just once in a blue moon maybe you can just go to make him happy.
....Of course, then he told you that if you don't go with him he'll break up with you. You know what.... personally my gut reaction if I were you would have been to tell him don't bother, then, because I am breaking up with you right now. I am an adult (and I assume you are a well) so I personally have no room in my life for those kind of immature childish games.
Now, maybe I am over-reacting. I don't know. Sometimes people do say really stupid things, and escalate things needlessly when they are upset. Maybe he didn't mean it and will later realize he was being an idiot.... but still, I don't personally agree with that kind of immaturity. That is not something you should ever say unless you truly mean it, and you should never use it as some kind of ultimatum.
Now, a couple other things to clarify if you don't mind. When he has taken you to your concerts, are they for music he enjoys as well, or have they been for music he does not? Has he ever expressed disinterest, but took you anyway, or has he never said anything? I only ask because if your concerts have been for music he does not like at all, but he's taken you anyway, then really it is only fair that you do the same for him now and then.
On the other hand, if they've been for music he enjoys as well, then he has no right to hold that against you, because he's going as much for himself as he is for you. Or, if it is music he doesn't really like and he's only been going for you.... but he never told you that so you thought he was going because he enjoyed it too, then it also isn't fair to hold that against you.
When it comes right down to it, though, neither of you should really be forced to go to something if you aren't really going to enjoy it. Go together to things you both enjoy, and leave the ones you don't to other groups. I do understand that you and your friends don't drive, so that makes it harder for you to get to things if he doesn't take you, but there are other ways you can figure it out if it is something you REALLY want to do.
I still don't condone his method, but I can at least maybe understand how he feels if he's always taking you to things you want to do, but then feels you are never open to his things.
Not being closer to the situation, I can't necessarily know if he's as immature as he sounds in this story, of if maybe he's just reacting badly to feeling unappreciated. Just going based on what you've shared, I can't help but feel like he sounds like an immature child who needs to grow up. All the same, though, if you are maybe taking him for granted (even though I am sure that is not your intention) it could make him feel unappreciated, and could cause him to act immaturely like this. Not saying that makes it okay, just saying even the best of us are sometimes not our best selves when upset.
And again, I don't know if that is the case, so I can't say. I just try to offer ideas for both sides of the argument in hopes that it will help you in some way. It is also possible that this isn't REALLY the issue, that he has other concerns and is therefore blowing this more out of proportion than he otherwise would. So, maybe talk to him about whether this really is the problem or if he has other things he wants to talk about.
Good luck to you either way. On the surface, this ALONE certainly doesn't sound like enough of an issue that either you or he should be considering breaking up.... but if it is just a symptom of other underlying problems, then maybe it is. I hope this works out for you in whatever way winds up being for the best.