Ok, so it's been a couple of weeks since we started "officially dating" and I realized that I wasn't totally sure I was ready.
I tried to just talk to him about it, and he even admitted that we didn't know each other that well. He said he doesn't just fall into bed with people, and that it was "our passion" that really sealed it for him. He through out a few other compliments about liking me, that I'm not vain enough to repeat here, but he used terms like, "looking for the right one," and "You may not be the right one, but you could be."
We discussed how he is a hopeless romantic, and I am a realist.
The thing is, I really was not trying to break-up with this guy. But then he started talking about ex-girlfriends who cheated on him, and how he has had his heart-broken. My take is, well we all have sweetheart. Maybe not super mushy, but I'm being realistic. I was just trying to say, we don't know each other very well, and because of that fact, I would like to take things slowly.
Maybe I'm just over-thinking it, but I was trying to share my thoughts as a way of getting to know him better. But also trying to explain that I am feeling a tad scared, and I would rather let him know than pretend I'm not and have it sit in me like a monster.
I'd say for a deeper feelings conversation it didn't go as well as I'd hoped, and left me feeling even more unsure. He seemed almost scared that I was breaking up with him, and didn't seem to understand that I was just trying to talk. But he said he thinks we compliment each other very well, while I kind am sitting there picking him apart in my head.