I'm similar Nina. I just can't take him as someone I can get serious with. I would stare at him wondering what on earth he is doing.
I thought I was a playful lady myself but I don't get into these types of plays. I have brothers and I guess the man quickly goes into the "friends only" category if he does that to me. And the kicking/poking is not cool to me. The teasing I assume was things like, "hey big booty" or "you look like a pig" rofl. I don't like name calling or that kind of tease. Other types of tease are fine. :evil: Ticking and wrestling...no. Chasing maybe but that would be a rare thing and would get old very quickly. "The talking all manly in their "gruffy" voice"--I don't know what that looks or sounds like.
I can see him doing the nicknames and the jokes...depending on what they are.
According to the OP, it sounds to me that the boyfriend would do these things often. It reminds me too much of high school and really before high school ...no thank you. I would probably not be sexually attracted to him. If I had a choice between playful boyfriend as in the example by the OP or conservative sexiness, I choose the latter. Hmmm, serious, sexy..wine and dining in a dim room with soft music. Afterward we slow dance and caress and kiss and feed each other grapes....now, that's the play that turns me on. Yes, hmmm. :D
OH back to the topic: when a guy does those things it usually means he likes you.