XP vs. Vista ... Which to choose?

Come on, people ... Help me out here ... I just ordered a new PC and it comes with Windows Vista Home Premium pre-installed. I've been using XP pro since I got it pirated in 2001. I've been satisfied with it.

What I'm wondering is whether or not I should just reformat the new desktop with XP again or stick with Vista?

I don't do any gaming. I do a fair amount of video/audio editing and re/encoding. Other than that, mostly school sh*t and internet surfing ... perhaps a download or few.

My current setup is an AMD Athlon XP 2800+ and I'm be jumping to an Intel Core 2 Quad-core by next week ...

So, techies ... what'll it be? XP or Vista?

I'm using Vista and I am a gamer but I do everything else pretty much too. No problems, runs awesome, and love it more than I ever did my XP. It eats 200mb or RAM to run windows more than Xp but it is worth it. I don't know about editing software enough to decided for you though.

XP is all you need if you're just word processing and browsing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Frasbee [Dear Guest/Member you have to reply to see the link.click here to register]

XP is all you need if you're just word processing and browsing.

---

It seems like he has both though and is trying to decide which one to use.

Ah, might as well just use vista if you have the resources.

I currently have XP, but my incoming desktop will have Vista on it. Another concern was whether or not some of my old hardware could be transferred without having driver issues ...

I find Vista to be Not-Ready-For -Prime-Time. I've been pretty happy with XP, though I admit, I held on to 2000 Pro like it was a lifeline for way too long. I've found XP to be stable, which is the best compliment I can give it, as it pretty much exists as a backbone to support all of my other applications.

I don't trust the Vista. I have to say, though, that O-V's wholesale endorsement gives me a certain amount of confidence.

I was on the phone with Amy last night, which is why my responses were so brief.

Basically, I'd prefer XP on a laptop, because Vista is just a system hog. I changed the theme over to the classic style, pretty much doing away with all the pretty effects. Otherwise, it essentially runs the same. You'll probably want to turn off the "User Account Control", when you get it. Essentially, every time you go to tinker with the settings/install/uninstall something, this little prompt will ask you whether you want to deny the action or continue.

It's really annoying.

Just look it up on-line, I'm sure you'll find the how-to, because it took me awhile to find it. They didn't put where any logical person would think they would, like in the Security Center under "User Account Control".

personally i have never used vista, nor have i heard much about it. however, i have a friend that works at supergeeks... (yup, me friends with a geek huh). however, i will ask him a few questions the next time that i see him and get some opinions.

raverboy

I prefer Linux with Wine over Vista. Get XP. Maybe in a year or two, all the bullshit will be taken care of for vista.

Choose the blue one

Based on your requirements, XP is really all you need. But with an intel 2-quad core, you have a pretty good laptop. What's the ram? If its 1gb, go for xp. If it's more than 2 gb, then you can consider vista.

My overall advice is to stick to XP, until all the compatibility issues are fixed on vista. If you like the looks better, you can download a vista skin for your xp. Google "vista transformation pack"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lilwing [Dear Guest/Member you have to reply to see the link.click here to register]

I prefer Linux with Wine over Vista. Get XP. Maybe in a year or two, all the bullshit will be taken care of for vista.

---

Yea, the problem though is that this "bullshit" that needs to be taken care of is actually bullshit. There is no bullshit with Vista. I am using Vista on the same computer I used my XP pro on and Vista is BETTER in EVERYWAY! Except that it eats 200mb of ram more. That is done in order to run windows aero which adds little graphical touches to icons and a flipping mode through the explorer windows. Both which can be disabled. I understand though that people always have trouble accepting something new because they don't want to let go of what they already have.

I'm also fan of Linux now. At work, I still use Windows, though.

So, the desktop I got was a Dell. After much thought, I decided I was going to reformat the thing with XP Pro. When I booted the XP disc from startup, it loaded a bunch of files and blue screened on me saying that the computer had to shut down to prevent damage to the PC.

I guess that was Dell's way of saying, you're stuck with Vista. I've been toying around with it and haven't had an compatibility issues yet, so I may just keep it around. SP1 will be coming around next month, so hopefully that helps ...

But ... it feels good to be able to do more than 2 things at a time! haha

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Only-virgins [Dear Guest/Member you have to reply to see the link.click here to register]

Yea, the problem though is that this "bullshit" that needs to be taken care of is actually bullshit. There is no bullshit with Vista. I am using Vista on the same computer I used my XP pro on and Vista is BETTER in EVERYWAY! Except that it eats 200mb of ram more. That is done in order to run windows aero which adds little graphical touches to icons and a flipping mode through the explorer windows. Both which can be disabled. I understand though that people always have trouble accepting something new because they don't want to let go of what they already have.

---

Well yeah, it's very inconvenient. Compatibility issues and inconvenience make up the majority of the problems with Vista. If you aren't experiencing any of these problems, you probably don't do much on your computer.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lilwing [Dear Guest/Member you have to reply to see the link.click here to register]

Well yeah, it's very inconvenient. Compatibility issues and inconvenience make up the majority of the problems with Vista. If you aren't experiencing any of these problems, you probably don't do much on your computer.

---

If you/someone runs into compatibility problems than I am sorry and maybe vista is not for you/them . I do a lot on my computer, I play games and use music programs...plus the typical PC stuff as well. I have built my own PC piece by piece and ran both windows now for a while. Only one game gave me an issue but I have had huge decline in blue screens of death...in fact with vista they are none existent. I am using the 32bit edition...just in case someone brings that up because I know that the 64 bit one has more driver issues.

So I guess I am just saying from personal experience.

Day 3 and I haven't had any issues other than a few software install problems, but was able to download patches and .dll's for them ...

I've stripped Vista to be as "classic" as possible ... I don't need all the extra 3D stuff ... but the system is running well ... Anyway, I'm pretty satisfied thus far ... we'll see where it goes.