I'm not sure if I'm just letting my trust issues get the better of me or if I have a reason to be suspicious. My fiancé has a chronic illness that was just diagnosed last year, so he started working online from home. So he's there alone every day, a lot of the time at the same times one of our attractive female neighbors is. I come home and see most of the time (from the cars in the parking lot) that he and her are the only people there a lot of the time. Anyway, he and I were leaving our apartment about three months ago and as we walked to our car in the parking lot I noticed that he walked up to our neighbor's car's passenger side door instead of ours. Her car is a lot bigger than ours and is white while ours is grey, so it's not like he mistook her car for ours. He says he was just really stoned and not paying attention, and we had been smoking pot right beforehand.
I also brought up how loud I've noticed she is (slamming doors, blasting bass all night) and he mentioned her having a bad stereo system in her car. I don't know how he would know this, he says he looked out our window one night and saw what he thought were her brake lights in the parking lot with loud bass coming from it and that's how he knows.
Also he has started complaining about how loud she is a lot more in the past month or so, and we've also been having sex a lot more in the past month. I thought maybe this was a sign he was having sex with her and broke it off? Or could it be a coincidence? Our other neighbor that was also really loud just moved out, and I think maybe he's just starting to realize a lot of the noise he's been hearing is the female neighbor, which he was blaming on the male neighbor that recently moved. So that's a believable reason he would just now start complaining about her. Plus why would he complain about her when he knows she might out their relationship to me if I complain to the leasing office about her or call the police for a noise complaint. She also has a boyfriend so that could be something that would deter her from ratting him out if he were to **** her over via me somehow.
One more could-be suspicious thing is that a white mark showed up on our car door a couple months ago, and it was obviously this female neighbor that parks next to us, and I said that's what I thought had happened and he vehemently disagreed with me, even though it was obvious from the position and color of the mark that she had done it when opening her car door... I thought maybe he thought she wouldn't do that because of their relationship?
Last suspicious thing was that he came inside one morning and told me she had talked to him in the parking lot. He had been lying under the car and she came out to go to her car and asked if he had a flat tire...which is a stupid question because anyone with eyes would have noticed the huge new dent he was working on. I thought maybe he was trying to cover up them talking to each other outside, incase I had seen them, and I would have clearly seen if I had looked out the window during that time.
One thing that I thought was pretty convincing of his innocence, which is why I'm so confused about this, was about a month ago I said I was gonna go ask a different neighbor that we're friendly with if he'd seen Laura (female neighbor I'm suspicious of) in my missing high heeled shoes, because at that point I was convinced he'd given a pair of high heels I'm missing to her...for some reason... Anyway when I said the name Laura he looked at me with what I thought was genuine surprise or confusion and said "who?? I don't even know who you're talking about". He has no reason to know her name as as far as I know they only talked that one time in the parking lot, so that's part of the story that makes sense, unless he was quickly lying.
If these things are suspicious to others, how do I find out for sure what's going on? I'm ashamed about this, but I already crept on his phone and facebook and didn't find anything, but there are a lot more ways than that to comminicate these days, not to mention that she's just a flight of stairs away from him.
I'm sorry this post was so long. I hope I can find some help anyway, because it's ruining my relationship, self confidence, sleep, everything. Thanks.
- - - Updated - - -
OH and this is really the last thing--about two weeks ago I walked past her on my way up the stairs, and she completely ignored me whereas she's always been friendly and said hello all the times before. Thought maybe they had broken it off and she blames me? Why would she be trying to talk to him in the parking lot and completely ignoring me all of a sudden?