Originally Posted by
damn2010
You're being VERY mature and very adult about this situation. I commend you.
You two keep playing emotional games and can't center what you all want. So you need to settle it down to a talk and make it clear cut! Either you give a relationship ANOTHER try now that you're older and wiser. Or you stop contacting each other and just "break away" so you can explore possible romantic relationships with OTHER people. The problem is because you stay in this perpetual "confusion" with him, it prevents you from physical and emotionally experiencing OTHER romantic relationships with other people! You would go on a date and then instantly compare the guy to your old b/f and he would get jealous and start chasing you only to "pull away" again. You then would mess things up with any potential good guys who come into your life. And vice-versa.
Call him and nail him down for a talk. If you get a voicemail, tell him you need to have a serious talk about your all's "friendship" and that if he doesn't get back to you soon that you're assuming that he doesn't want to speak and that you're moving on without him and not to contact you anymore. That should get his attention and if he doesn't reply, then it's clear he's done as well. Then it's no games and NO contact. Start healing from the mess.